I feel like making Indiana Jones an FPS is a really bad idea business-wise

[Gimmick]

Do you feel like me, that going FPS is gonna halve the sales potential? (or game pass engagement or whatever)

There is a significant amount of players who want an Uncharted-inspired Indiana Jones game. Tomb Raider became a massive success by going that route.

Xbox had a chance to have its very own Uncharted trilogy here.

The studio must do what it believes in and what they are best at, but I feel like Machine Games is missing the point of why people wanted an Indiana Jones game. They wanted it because they envisioned it as an Uncharted/Tomb Raider game with a whip.

Imagine making Call of Duty a third-person shooter, it might be fantastic, but it would completely miss the point of what the market wants.

 

[Lelouch0612]

Do you feel like me, that going FPS is gonna halve the sales potential? (or game pass engagement or whatever)

Discussion shouldn't be based on feelings but at least grounded in Sales data

Try to add a few datapoints in the OP and we'll open back the thread. Otherwise, the discussion won't be focused.